What consequences will the end of Internet neutrality have in the United States (and how will it affect the rest of the world)?

What consequences will the end of Internet neutrality have in the United States (and how will it affect the rest of the world)?


The digital world shuddered this Thursday in the United States.

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) of that country announced the total repeal of the Internet neutrality standards approved by the Barack Obama government in 2015, which prevented providers from charging additional fees for access faster to certain content on the network.

Basically, they were obliged to treat the entire digital universe equally, which, in political terms, meant that the authorities ensured that the companies that provide the service did not block, slow down or discriminate in any way any content or applications.

With the new law, everything will change.

The companies that provide the service will now have the freedom to experiment with new prices, prioritize or block content, without having to render accounts.

This could have great benefits for the suppliers, explains Ryan Singel, an expert in net neutrality at the Center for Internet Studies and the Society of Stanford University.

And this is due, he says, to that traditionally the telephone market in the United States has been very uncompetitive.

“We have only four large companies that provide wireless and broadband internet, which is terrible, and 51% of Americans have only one option to choose their Internet service, ” he adds.

With this new model, it is estimated that these companies will be able to raise much more money from the netizens and also invest in improvements for their services.

Comcast logo, one of the big companies providing broadband services.
Copyright of the REUTERS
Image captionLarge telecommunications companies such as Comcast may be the big beneficiaries of the new rules.

“By removing the restrictions, these suppliers will be the main beneficiaries , increase their profits, become more competitive and this will allow them to expand and improve the service or take it to smaller communities,” says the expert.

But if for companies it will bring benefits and in theory will help small communities to have greater access to the network, what will be the consequences that this could have for the vast majority of users or for companies that use Internet services in the United States? ?

And how can this affect the rest of the world?

Upload of connection prices

According to Singel, one of the first effects will be a rise in connection prices .

However, the specialist explains in an interview with BBC World that the main consequences will not be visible immediately and that they will not have a “direct” effect on current users, although they will be the most affected.

“The vote approved on Thursday allows the large Internet provider companies to find ways to charge more money to companies that are online , that is, allow them to raise prices if they want to have faster access to the Internet.”

Until now, any company that wants to use the network could do it regardless of its power or size.

Donald Trump
Copyright of the GETTY IMAGES
Image captionSince the arrival of Donald Trump to the White House, Republicans wanted to reverse the rules on net neutrality.

Had the same right a young programmer from a town in Massachusetts who wanted to open a blog or create an application on the benefits of beekeeping that a giant like Google.

But from now on, companies will be able to discriminate which users give more bandwidth or who will limit or cut services.

For the users

“It is good to say that the first consequences will not fall directly on individuals The fastest way to make money is behind the companies that are in the network, which in turn, will be reflected in the internet experience of ordinary users “says Singel.

The problem, he adds, is that the above will make the services we use online, such as streaming services (to watch videos or listen to music), become much more expensive as well.

Netflix screen
Copyright of the REUTERS image
Image captionNetflix is one of the services that may be affected.

” Netflix, for example, will become more expensive, as they will have to pay higher fees for using better quality internet to offer their services, they will need to charge their users more to maintain it, so we will see that the Internet will become much more expensive in the services for which you pay “, explains the specialist from Stanford University.

Other services, such as online sales, may also experience a price increase: when you have to pay more for the internet service, the prices on the products will also rise.

In the same way, as some companies will benefit over others, larger ones, such as Amazon, would benefit, while small entrepreneurs will see their sales possibilities reduced .

Also, the specialist believes that, in general, it could generate a “differentiated internet” for those who can pay more and for those who pay less.

“As it happens in some countries we can find that Internet services are sold in” packages “, as it happens with telephone plans or television channels, grouped according to the provider,” he says.

But it will not be there.

Less variety

Singel warns that there will also be fewer free services : since the companies that now offer this type of utilities will have to pay more, if they do not charge more they will become unviable from the economic point of view.

This, he says, will not affect the big companies that can pay for this.

The audience
Copyright of the GETTY IMAGES
Image caption The audience in which the end of neutrality on the internet was determined.

However, it could mean the end of smaller companies or the failure of new projects in the network.

“Given that the prices to have a better internet will rise and the suppliers will be able to control it at will, there will be fewer new companies in the network, there will be less variety and will keep the power concentrating on the internet giants and that there will be less possibilities for innovation and for plurality, “he says.

“It will be an Internet more controlled by the most powerful companies, there will be less possibilities for digital entrepreneurs to do their projects and will limit in general the freedom and variety of the network,” he says.


Another of the most controversial points of this new law is that Internet service providers may block or censor content for any reason.

“If Comcast and Verizon, for example, decide that we do not want to have sites that sell weapons, they can block those sites.” In the previous rules, companies were obligated to keep any page on their servers regardless of whether they were in favor or against their Now all that changes, “says Singel.

During the previous law, any service and any application were legal under US law and no one could interfere in that without a judicial or federal order. Now this prerogative belongs also to service providers.

Demonstration in the United States
Copyright of the GETTY IMAGES
Image caption Activists for internet rights protested against the decision made in the United States.

” Any company or blogger, for example, who advocates controversial speeches or controversial opinions could see their website censored or blocked ,” he says.

But since the Internet is a global phenomenon, the consequences will not be left only for the United States.

Global consequences

According to Singel, the lack of Internet variety and a “more boring” network will be one of the main global consequences of the elimination of net neutrality in the United States.

Other losers will be companies or even foreign users that host information on servers in that country.

“If a foreign company wants to use American Internet services to reach more users in that country, it can be found that it will not have the same capacity to distribute its contents as a local company or an Internet giant,” he says.

The possibilities of entering the US digital market, says the expert, will become more difficult, bureaucratic and will take processes in which it will be the Internet providers who will have the last word .

internet packages in portugal
Image caption 
A congressman from the United States shared on Twitter how in Portugal Internet packages are sold as if they were cable television.

A similar effect for companies, innovators, small businesses or applications that seek to host information on American servers: they may find that the speed to access them slows down or increases.

From now on, the nature or size of the company will guarantee that it has a better or worse internet service .

“There are companies outside the United States that may be asked to pay more if they want to reach Verizon or Comcast customers, for example, if they want to reach users of those companies,” he says.

Symbolic consequences

On the other hand, the expert points out that the consequences are not only on the practical level.

“For a long time, the United States had been a leader in Internet neutrality, an international example, and the law signed by Obama to regulate the Internet in 2015 has become an international milestone,” he says.

The new law, according to Singel, is “a very bad message for the rest of the world, because they show how the big telephone companies can dictate to governments what they have to do”.

Ajit Pai
Copyright of the GETTY IMAGES
Image captionAjit Pai, director of the Federal Communications Commission was a director at Verizon.

But, according to Singel, it could also have political consequences within the American society.

“It is good to clarify that it is a measure that is taken despite widespread opposition from public opinion , from experts and that transcends even the classic division of opinion between Republicans and Democrats,” he says.

A survey published this week by the University of Maryland indicated that 83% of Americans opposed the change in the law. Only among Republicans, the level of opposition was 75%.

“This, logically, is also negative for the image of the government, because it is something that the people did not want, but they did not listen to it and approved it anyway, that’s not a good way to make people believe in democracy and in democratic processes, “he concludes.

About author
Profile photo of Rava Desk

Rava Desk

Rava is an online news portal providing recent news, editorials, opinions and advice on day to day happenings in Pakistan.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *